Oddly enough, when you look at his 1v1 defense on synergy sports, the numbers stack up pretty well compared to players like Bogut, Horford, Bosh, Nene, even KG. That doesn't mean that his team defense is great (or even good), but it was somewhat surprising. His post up defense seems to be pretty good. Also, his assist/game and AST% are fairly comparable to players like Bogut, Nene, Kaman and Lopez.
isn't that precisely the sort of defender who fits in well next to KG? a guy who struggles on team defense / with rotations but is at least solid man-to-man, particularly as a defender in the post against traditional big men?
sounds a lot like shaq last year to me.
What? Absolutely not.
I can't begin to describe how frustrating it was to watch Garnett bust his ass for 20 seconds and then to have the opposition score because the other big failed to rotate to stop an open layup.
not saying it's an ideal setup defensively, but that players of that sort can fit in next to KG and be part of a very solid defense. even if shaq was frustrating at times last year, his deficiencies were not much more extreme than those of glen davis, or even of perk. while he's been a very good post defender for a long time, perk is by no means a perfect defensive player. he was definitely a liability against certain matchups and certain types of offenses.
regardless, even with some very frustrating running mates, our team defense has always been very good as long as KG is playing. i wouldn't expect that to change much with Big Al.
the point is, we can afford for our team defense to suffer a little bit. the reason our team has fallen short the last couple of years is primarily, in my opinion, because our offense -- despite being generally quite efficient -- is below average, especially in the fourth quarter. we totally lack players who can create their own shot, most of all when opposing defenses clamp down the hardest at the end of the game.
if we have to sacrifice our league-leading defense a bit to make our offense solidly above average, then so be it. just as a top offense isn't worth much if your defense is atrocious, a top defense is great, but only leads to limited success if your offense is inconsistent, unreliable, and overall pretty mediocre.